Retailers often face backlash when making changes to their loyalty programs, as customers expect consistent rewards. Rising costs—due to technology, customer service, and marketing expenses—are forcing many businesses to scale back perks. However, how these changes are communicated can make all the difference in maintaining customer loyalty.
Retailers like Sephora, Able, Best Buy, and GameStop have all made adjustments recently, such as reducing perks or altering membership fees. While some customers were frustrated, transparency and clear communication helped soften the impact. For example, Able’s openness about financial challenges eased disappointment, while GameStop's stock price rose despite mixed reviews.
Effective communication is key. Retailers should engage top members first, explain the reasons behind changes, and use personalized messaging to maintain trust. In the end, clear and strategic communication helps preserve customer loyalty even when program perks are scaled back.